Showing posts with label Dharma Productions. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Dharma Productions. Show all posts

Sunday, September 5, 2010

We Are Family | The Critique

Rating: 3/5



Long ago, I heard Kareena saying that Erin Brockovich is one of her dream roles. With We Are Family, I guess a part of her dream has been realized. But unfortunately, Kareena is no Julia Roberts. She can’t be so even in my wildest dreams. However, rating We Are Family, I would say… 3 off five. Two for movie and one for buying the rights of original...




We are family is basically story of a lady coming into terms with her ex’s current for the sake of her children. Kajol, the Mom is trying to teach a thing or two to Kareena, the Stepmom while Arjun, the Pop looks confused and ragged between two ladies. Set in Australia, this is another tale from Dharma Banner about no-so-Indian Indians. Without revealing the details and goof-ups in the plot, I would like to say a few things about the performances.

We Are Family is basically Kajol’s film. She simply overtook everything from everyone else with her charming performances. She has proven the fact that she is perhaps the last star actress. Maybe this is not her best but she was the saving grace. Kareena was better than Tashan or Kambakhht Ishq but I guess that’s not a reason to celebrate. Arjun was apt and with raised expectations after Raajneeti, I think he should gear up fast. Kids were cool. They put a nice show.


Dialogues are a sheer let down. Too plastic. Music is average. Cinematography and editing are just okay; below Dharma standards. Direction seems to be weak but then I guess since we tempt to compare with the original; so pardonable. Overall, average. However, I think it was absolutely great on part of makers that they bought the rights for the remake… something really positive.

Why To Watch: If you haven’t seen Stepmom, like Kajol act and want to ogle at Kareena.

Why To Avoid: There is nothing too good about it, in parts its boring and not anywhere close to Stepmom in cinematic sense.

Written By: Sujoy Ghosh

Friday, October 16, 2009

Wake Up Sid! | Critique

Who is Sid? Sid is a boy who lives next to your house. He may or may not be as charming as Ranbeer but still lives his life to the fullest without giving a damn to anything serious, especially the one called Future (an F-word). He lives with a friend, Ayesha who has aspirations to grow and achieve something in life. Technically both are poles; the opposite ones in approach. Ayesha works with a local magazine and have a crush over her magazine editor. What happens between Sid and Ayesha and what Sid learns about life and himself is the story of the movie.

Is that a classic? No, but still I would like to watch it again for the same reasons that made Dil Chahta Hai and pre-IMA-Lakshya my faves (though post IMA was equally cool). The movie revolves around characters that are realistic and have the freshness of new cosmos. We don’t live like Sid but at some point in our lives, we all are/ were like him only. Ayaan Mukherjee (Director) had a simple story, simple characters and made a lovable movie out of it. Impressive for a debut.

Ranbeer as Sid was an apt choice. He has done a nice job but could have been better. The comfort level with the character of an easy going guy was better in Lakshya where Hrithik did the job. But Ranbeer can be rated as a good second. Konkona was great as usual. Watching her living characters is a delight to soul.

Last thing. Music was nice but not upto Shankar-Ehasaan-Loy tio’s standards. ‘Iktara’ is the only song that will have a long lasting influence on public memory. For details; read: Music Review by Vinayak

Overall, a nice movie. Watch it as it’s a better choice over Acid Factory.

Written By: Sujoy Ghosh