Friday, February 1, 2013

The Verdict | The Critique

The biggest trick in 3-Act structure lies in how climax is revealed to audience. The way The Verdict presents failure and success of Jury System in single vein, any day it stands at par with a classic like 12 Angry Men and Anatomy of a Murder. Like 12 Angry Men, The Verdict is a Sidney Lumet movie. Brilliance thus established again for the zillionth time.
 
The Verdict starts with Frank (played by a brilliant Paul Newman) who is at the abyss of his life – personal and professional. As a favor from a friend, he gets a case of medical malpractice. It’s a routine case suited for out of court settlement. The accused facility offers him a handsome settlement amount but he refuses the offer. He thinks that his case can be his last chance to make a point as a lawyer, a goal he set for himself in his early days. Against the odds, he fights the case. Will justice prevail?
 
Based on novel by the same name, unlike 12 Angry Men, The Verdict relies much on gesture than dialogues. Paul Newman and James Mason are two sides of the courtroom segment. Their performance keep audience on toes. The other aspect of the story, i.e. Frank’s story is explored in detail. The grittiness in the characters when cornered comes out well and seems both heroic and justified at the same time.
 
Technically, The Verdict is sound. Good background music, good cinematography (some signature shots from classic era) and tight script. With his direction, Sidney Lumet presents a brilliant case study for all budding directors. Rated as rank 4 courtroom drama by AFI, The Verdict is a must watch for cine buffs.
 
Written By: Sujoy Ghosh
 

Salim Mirza In Garam Hava | Actor's Eye

Garm Hava or Scorching Winds, as the subtitles suggest, is I feel one of the best and amongst the must watch movies in the category which deals with the subject of post partition atrocities faced by the common man, to be more particular by the Muslims who stayed back, in India.
 
The story of the film unfolds at its own pace slowly and steadily making you a part of the day to day life and problems of the Mirza family, headed by Salim Mirza. The character of Salim Mirza, through Balraj Sahni, tells its viewers how to follow your heart in spite of being in unfavorable conditions. In conditions where your loved ones are moving to an altogether and newly formed country whereas you are staying back; in conditions where your business is being hit because you have always worked on your own terms and want to continue with the same; in conditions when you have to mortgage your house of many decades to make your ends meet; in conditions when your children are not getting jobs because of communal prejudices; in conditions where your daughter is under mental trauma for the fact that all eligible bachelors have moved to the new country; and these all being just a part of the bigger picture. Balraj Sahni has played all emotions, and as his reputation goes, he has played them all very well. He has done it in a very subtle yet effective way. He shows the pain of loss, the love of a father, the care for an ailing mother, the hard work of a good businessman, the fear of one day giving in to the surmounting situations and many more.
 
In all a very nice movie and some very nicely power packed performances by all the actors. No doubt that apart from being the debut movie of a fine actor Mr. Farooq Sheikh, some very fine performances by the very respected Balraj Sahni, playing the lead character of Salim Mirza, A.K. Hangal, Yunus Parvez and others this movie also boasts about being India’s official entry to The Oscars for the year 1974 in the best foreign language film category and many other national and international awards.
 
Written By: Gaurav Karmakar

2013 - Year Around | Eyes Read It

2013 is definitely year of sequels, remakes and adaptations– both qualitatively and quantitatively. In 2 months we have seen Race 2, Murder 3 and Kai Po Che. Well, only third one was able to earn some brownie points. Race 2 and Murder 3 hardly raised any emotion.
 
Major Sequels in 2013: Race 2, Murder 3, Saheb, Biwi Aur Gangster Returns, Shootout at Wadala, Aashiqui 2, Yamla Pagla Deewana 2, Once Upon a Time in Mumbaai 2, Ragini MMS 2, Krrish 3, Dhoom 3
 
Major Remakes in 2013: Himmatwala, Chashme Buddoor Remake, Zanjeer, Ramaiya Vasta Vaiya
 
Major Adaptations in 2013: Kai Po Che!, Lootera, Ram Leela
 
Among the ones which are yet to be released, Saheb, Biwi Aur Gangster Returns, Once Upon a Time in Mumbaai 2, Dhoom 3, Chashme Buddoor Remake and Lootera will be the ones to look out for. 2013, I hope some good surprises are in store.
 
 
 

Wednesday, January 16, 2013

Results | Blue Notebook | Editor's Pen

Hello everybody!!!

This year’s Blue Notebook truly reflects the spirit of cinema. What an year 2012 was. Incredible, to say the least. We saw alternate cinema getting a strong ground in mainstream cinema, we saw indie doing so well and we saw emergence of actors, who till now were part of the crowd nobody remembered. What an year…

Three technical Categories… Best Art Direction. This was supposed to be tricky as the nominations covered a range rarely seen before. India won. The sleepy urban Kolkata and fiery raw rural Wasseypur. Yes… the honors goes to Kahaani and Gangs Of Wasseypur. The second technical category was Best Editing. Frankly, we found that there was hardly any contest. The most well edited movie of the year was Kahaani. Last and perhaps our favourite – Best Music. Vicky Donor seemed to lead the chart till the last morning and we saw an Usain Bolt in Cocktail who grabbed the award in the last moment with a small… real small difference.

We always argue that Bollywood, more than often, lack good stories. 2012 will be remembered as an exception. We had great stories. Kahaani, story of a pregnant women takes entire nation hostage with love, affection and care. Who would have thought that we will have a thriller there, I mean a thriller of that sort. However, the Best Story was an equally mesmerizing story of a couple, a doctor and a sperm donor. Chadhdhaji’s Vicky Donor turned out to be real Aryaputra.

National awards are dominated by regional cinema. Here goes our little tribute. Best Regional Language Film – Kaksparsh which won a close battle with Eega. The way we see cinema within India, we explore beyond borders as well. Along with blockbusters, we had  a small Kenyan movie as well. The Best Foreign Language Film was a contest between two films. The Dark Knight Rises lost. Argo won.
Coming back to mainstream…

Most compelling performances would include likes of Manoj Bajpayee, Tigmanshu Dhulia and Richa Chaddha in Gangs Of Wasseypur, Irrfan Khan in Paan Singh Tomar, Vidya Balan in Kahaani, Anjali Patil in Chakravyuh and Ranbeer Kapoor in Barfi. Contest was tough. Votes were split and there were many close calls. The Best Actor Male for 2012 was Irrfan Khan closely defeating Tigmanshu Dhulia. From Votes point of view, in the Best Actor Female category, we had a clear winner… Vidya Balan. Going by her records in Blue Notebook, we will have to think about giving her Lifetime Achievement Award soon. Chronic Offender.

Best Director! The winner has fought against odds. Over the time he has become symbol of rebellion in Hindi Cinema. People say he is the posterboy of Indian Indie. The award goes to Anurag Kashyap. However, it’s worth mentioning that it was a close call between Anurag, Dibakar and Sujoy. Brilliant cinema. Brilliant filmmakers.

Now the most awaited one. What was the best film of 2012. Its difficult to point out one winner. We have two joint winners. A tie shows the intensity of contest. The Best Film of 2012 are Gangs Of Wasseypur and Paan Singh Tomar. Rural India swept the country off its feet.

On that note, lets hope that 2013 will raise the mark.

Love
Sujoy Ghosh

5 Bollywood Movies Which Defined 2012 | Under Lens

Paan Singh Tomar: Bollywood usually present lame biopics. Even one like Guru disappoints with all gloss and glitter. After Shekhar Kapur’s Bandit Queen, we finally had a biopic which held subject with compassion but didn’t made a martyr out of it. Interestingly both Phoolan and Paan Singh were contemporaries. Paan Singh was a champion turned dacoit. He died a death of dacoit. He lived a life of athlete. Abuse he faced as a villager can be the reason why he picked up gun but reason was definitely not justified. Dhulia, as director made no such attempt.   
Kahaani: When was the last time you saw a city as raw and natural? Kahaani was a brilliant medley of lot of things – a good story, interesting twist, strong characters, competitive actors and subtle music. Kahaani worked on two levels – emotional where viewer connects with the tragedy and trauma of a pregnant woman and affection of a young vulnerable cop and secondly as a thriller where viewer gets one of the biggest shock of their life, just below their belt.
 
Gangs Of Wasseypur: Pulp Fiction of India? Comparisons with Tarantino and Guy Ritchie might be a little far-fetched, spells out the word pretty good. GOW is one of those movies which can take on word. Yes, influences are there. You can see QT and GR written all over. You can see glimpses of City Of God. Still, the brilliance on screen will be unadulterated Indian pulp fiction seen with different lenses.  
 
Vicky Donor: Sperms!!! A taboo subject handled with love, humor and wisdom. Rare for a Bollywood film. Even if you keep performances and music aside, the story in itself is such a pleasure. The way story has been woven around characters and caricatures is simply brilliant. I agree that having good actors and spicing it up with good music helps, it should not take away anything from the writers… the third and strongest pillar.
 
Barfi: Scenes were copied. Accepted. So? Does that make Barfi a bad movie? If we keep aside plagiarism for a while, Barfi comes out as a lovely story of a guy who cannot speak or hear but lives and loves more than anyone. His handicap is not a bane. He doesn’t reason much when it comes to love. His innocent definition of true friendship can move even the slyest of all. Handicapped should be called differently abled… Barfi subtly tells us why…