Saturday, December 5, 2009

Paa Movie Review | Critique


The hall was completely silent when Auro entered the frame. Not a single person made the slightest sound. Including me. I, alongwith, several others were witnessing something of a phenomenon. Amitabh Bachchan-virtually unrecognizable, the famous baritone of his vanished- I sat there bewildered.


Amitabh Bachchan, THE MAN has exemplified the very fact that no CGI, no prosthetics can take away from the character. In this character AB finds a rein, grips it and goes galloping. he becomes the character. Such is AB's performance.

PAA the second outing from director R. Balki is a humorous and emotional take on a 12-year old kid named Auro (played by AB) who is suffering from a rare disease Progeria. It is a condition which makes Auro look like a 12 year old trapped in a body aged about 65. The characters who form the world of Auro are played by Vidya Balan (his mother), Arundhati Naag (his doting granny), Abhishek Bachchan (his father) and a few friends. I don't believe that a critique should emphasise on providing the story to readers. So, my advice, my sincerest advice actually- you need to go see PAA, pronto! It is not without its share of faults, yes. There are cliches and a lot of digressions but overall, the film is a well-balanced product. (albeit with that extremely manipulative ending).

There are some moments which will cause a lump in your throat and also some in which your sides will ache from continuous laughter. Much of the humor is provided by the excellent Prateek Katare who plays Auro's best friend Vishnu. A quirky little character, he delivers lines with furious confidence that generates genuine laughs, not forcefully. Vidya Balan as Auro's mother is spot-on as she delivers one of her finest performances. Her pain resides in her eyes and is almost tangible. Except for once scene where she goes yackety-yak shouting "Just because you gave me your bloody sperm doesn't mean blah-blah-blah".. I shifted uncomfortably in my seat because that piece of gratuituous dialogue took away much of the friction from the confrontation between Abhishek and Vidya.

Arundhati Naag is excellently cast and she is delightful as Auro's granny.

Abhishek Bachchan doesn't do anything different except trying to be too uber cool. No, I am not saying he turns in a ridiculous performmance but that smug look on his face has to go.

The film could have done away with some of the meandering moments like Abhishek's politics. It extends for the most part and overstays its welcome. The music by Illaiyaraja is soothing and varies largely as well. PC Sreeram's cinematography lends to the films lushy and frothy look. And what is with the quick-cuts the editor is obsessed with? It is an interesting device but too quick to jump the gun just defeats the fun.

So, that leaves us with the Big B. AB is the heart and soul of this film turninng in what can be best described as a text-book performance that film students will be happy to do the anatomy of. There are many reasons to prove that AB is God and PAA is just one of them. Make room Pacinos and De Niros, for when AB cometh, you better give him his space.

PAA deserves to be watched because some of the spectacular performances and also because the disesase is not the centroid of this film. If you take the Progeria factor out, Auro is the same mischievious boy whom you sat next to in school. PAA is good....just not the great film it aims to be

Still, it deserves a watch. AB fans have all the right reasons to celebrate.

Rating - ***

Written By Gyandeep Pattanayak

13 comments:

Ali Naqvi said...

Cant wait too see Mr. Bachchan as Auro, the review make me want to see it !

Unknown said...

though yet not a very big fan of B, yet wud love to watch one of his lifetime performances

Gyandeep said...

Hey Ali, please do see the movie. AB Sr rocks!

Gyandeep said...

Hi Neha, please please please do watch PAA and tell me how you felt about it. AB is KABOOM-explosive!

rishabh shukla said...

very well written review gyandeep...gud job! :)

mansi said...

saw paa this sunday and absolutely loved it..it made me laugh,it made me cry and i left d hall with a very satisfied feeling..satisfaction of a gr8 movie experience..d flaws of d movie r minor nd dey never really become a hinderance...coz d movie keeps u engaged through nd through!!
but i disagree abt abhishek's performance..i read in masand's review as well dat he behaves like a smug..nd all..but honestly..i didn't feel it..i thought he played d young nd confident politician 2 perfection and his sober performance was a perfect foil for big b's vivacious act!!!
but overall..as i said earlier..as i left d hall..i had a tear in my eye nd a smile on my face..lovely film after a long long time!!!!

Gyandeep said...

Rishabh,

Thanks again buddy. Saw the film or not? You will love it.

Gyandeep said...

Mansi,

Good that you enjoyed the film. I enjoyed it too. But, don't you think Abhishek has been giving a repetitive performance of late. I mean, the one-tone-expression. I am only saying that he doesn't bring any difference to his acting mannerisms. He was absolutely different in Yuva and Guru, for instance. That aside, I am really glad that you liked the movie. I enjoyed it immensely too.

Cheers!

mansi said...

i think abhishek's strength is his eyes..very expressive..i especially love d scenes where abhi checks out auro's room 4 d first time..dat scene brought a tear 2 my eyes..i think it was d combined effect of d background score(wid gali mudhi playin in d background) nd d depth of his eyes dat rocked dat scene...but may be i m a huge fan..dats y i can feel it :)
but i have always felt dat ppl r a lill unfair when it comes 2 abhishek,,i mean i have found dat d gr8 irrfan khan's expression r d same in a lot of films(take newyork,slumdog,rog etc..)but in his case ppl call it "intensity"..while wid abhi dey become a bit wicked!!!

rishabh shukla said...

yeah buddy saw it just yesterday...d emotional moments were captured quite well n i luved d kid! n his friend vishnu..paa boasts of some realli gud performances...n ofcourse the makeup artists were damn gud! :)

Gyandeep said...

Mansi,

C'mon yaar! How can you compare Abhishek and Irrfan. I said Abhishek acts well, just not different. Irrfan has a varied range. He can be funny, villainous, sweet....that MAN is worth everything you want to risk to go see a film of his. PURE TALENT. Irrfan has never given a singular performance. Be it Haasil or Slumdog Millionaire or The Warrior, tat man is a pleasure to watch.

And yes, I agree about you being an AB Junior fan. Count me in too, because I loved him in Yuva, Sarkar, Guru but repeated expressions everywhere--Drona, Paa....no, thanks.

mansi said...

hey gyandeep!!i think..this can go for quite a long time!!arguments nd counter arguments!!.. i guess..lets end by saying dat movie watching(or probably actor-watching..in this case)is an entirely subjective nd personal experience....nd as some ppl say.."we can agree to disagree sometimes"!!

Gyandeep said...

Mansi

Alrighty Almighty! We will agree to disagree, then :)

Post a Comment

WE WOULD LOVE TO HEAR FROM YOU, POST COMMENTS TO TELL US WHAT YOU THOUGHT OF THIS ARTICLE,

Finding it difficult to post comments ??
type your comment in white box below and under "Comment as" Drop down list, either:

1. select "Anonymous"
OR
2. If you are logged into Google account, select your Google account from the drop-down list